News:

Welcome to our site!

Main Menu

Will Putin Invade Ukraine?

Started by Cassia, January 20, 2022, 01:29:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hydra009

Quote from: Cassia on June 23, 2024, 03:47:00 PMMuslim terrorists are at work again in Russia.
One year to the day of Prigozhin's almost-rebellion.  The Dagestan locals are looking to make it a tradition.

I've read some preliminary reports about this incident.  I can't go into details because the details are still coming in.  But suffice it to say that it was shockingly violent and chaotic - it just goes to show how much Moscow's hold over the other regions has deteriorated.

Hydra009

In footage that I'm surprised isn't even the 4th most shocking thing I've seen today, a russian infantry took a grazing hit by a small fpv drone and was very quickly and casually Old Yellered by his nearby "comrade", who barely paused his march.

This dude almost certainly could have survived.  At the very least, there could've been some perfuctory attempt at first aid.  Instead, the other guy did his best Kristi Noem impression.  Barbarous.  Anybody like that in a western military unit would get court martialed or perhaps killed on sight by the rest of his squad.  Because you can't work with someone you can't trust and you can't trust someone who does stuff like that.

It just goes to show how little Russian lives are valued by other Russians.

Hydra009

#4037

Top recent news:

Ukraine hit a Russian command post  The telegram post reports several Russian officers as well as the commander KIA.  Awaiting confirmation.

Crimea river: Russian air defense reportedly did successfully intercept an ATACMS missile, but they bizarrely did it over a crowded beach, which inadvertently (I hope it was inadvertent) rained cluster munitions near civilians - civilians vacationing in AN ACTIVE WARZONE not far from a military base in a country they definitely weren't invited to - the dictionary definition of invasion.  I feel sorta bad that some civilians were reportedly hurt/killed - but jeez louise, Crimea ain't exactly known as the safest place to be.  They knew it was risky AF.  And it's not like the Ukrainians didn't warn Russian civilians to stay away from Crimea.  And this isn't exactly the first time Russians got a rude awakening at a Crimean beach, so there's a zero percent chance they didn't know it wasn't safe.  No excuses.

Speaking of excuses, Russia of course blames the US for this.  And once again, Ukraine only has ATACMS because Ukraine is at war.  Ukraine is only at war because they're invaded.  Putin is responsible for everything, so save the bellyaching for Putin.  Everything Russians have sown, he's planted.  He decided to invade Ukraine, so he's responsible for every single Ukrainian and Russian death there as the result of his war of choice.  He's also responsible for the enlargement of NATO, the complete alienation of Ukraine from Russia, and the isolation of Russia from the world, replaced with the embrace of tin-pot dictators like Kim Jong Un.

Satellite images confirm destruction of Russian warehouse used to store shahed drones

Hydra009

#4038
Russia summons US ambassador over Crimean missile attack

I hope they send this guy:


Russia again threatens
Quote"You should ask my colleagues in Europe, and above all in Washington, the press secretaries, why their governments are killing Russian children," Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov told reporters.

At least two children were killed in the attack on Sevastopol on Sunday, according to Russian officials. People were shown running from a beach near Sevastopol and some of the injured being carried off on sun loungers. Kyiv did not comment on the attack but denies targeting civilians.
That sort of grandstanding is giving off serious Kane in Tiberian Dawn vibes ("how could GDI do this??" *shoots cameraman*)

But I love answering dumb questions so I'll answer his dumbass question:

Every Russian who crosses from the internationally-recognized Russian border into Ukraine without permission should be considered dead.  Soldiers, men, women, children, etc.  All dead.  Dead from the instant they step foot onto Ukrainian soil without permission.  This is not to imply that they are targeted as Ukrainian children are targeted by Russian soldiers - Ukraine is full of landmines and unexploded bombs and drones and burning Russian vehicles and living Russian soldiers - all of which are a threat to children.

Russians entering Ukraine are entering a warzone at best and participating in atrocities at worst.  All of that is criminal activity - from simple trespassing all the way to crimes against humanity, like the intentional slaughter of civilians at Bucha.  If, by some miracle, these people don't die and are merely apprehended or escape back to Russia or some other fate, they should count their blessings and reflect on the recklessness of their behavior.

If Boris and Natasha decide to recklessly drag little Putin to Crimea and they get hurt, it's their own choice and their own fault and they should take accountability for their own actions.  Similarly, Tsar Putin should accept his own role in the deaths of thousands of Russians and should make good on his stated desire for peace and immediately put an end to the bloodshed by withdrawing invading Russian troops.

A nation waging a war of aggression - waging an especially cruel and brutal one at that - cannot cry over spilled blood.

Cassia

Holy crap. Just saw video where a Russian BMP slows, and the sappers working the road direct him through a cleared path marked with yellow tape......and the BMP follows the path and immediately hits a mine.....BOOM !

Hydra009

Quote from: Cassia on June 25, 2024, 02:11:02 PMHoly crap. Just saw video where a Russian BMP slows, and the sappers working the road direct him through a cleared path marked with yellow tape......and the BMP follows the path and immediately hits a mine.....BOOM !
Filled with crew, too.  Possibly meat on top as well, afaik.


Hydra009

#4042
A bunch of bad news lately:

North Korea to send over some of its troops to Ukraine within a month or two.  Not to imply that they're some fearsome fighting force - they're not and they know that.  That's why they'll mostly be doing construction/engineering work in Donbass, freeing up Russian soldiers for more frontline duties.  At least, that's the theory.  In reality, it'll probably be the North Koreans on the front.

Russia has this weird habit of recruiting other countries' people to die in their wars (just ask Cuba, Syria, Nepal, India, and several African countries).  The theory is that Russians are willing to accept just about anything from Putin so long as they're not really affected, so they need catspaws to deflate Russian casualties.  But given just how willing both Putin and Russian citizens are to throw Russian lives away (~1200 casualties virtually every day with no end in sight) I dunno if I buy this idea.  I think that most Russians are perfectly okay with whatever and Tsar Putin no longer has to worry about what they like or don't like, it's just that Putin is desperate for more troops and he'll get them however he can.

I don't think this'll work out so well for Putin.  Ukraine chews through around 1200/day, so unless North Korea is planning on committing massive numbers, this is a delaying tactic at best and won't make any difference at all at worst.

Russia also expects to sign some sort of deal with Iran soon, likely on "energy projects" (Iran's nuclear program)  As much as I'd love to see Israel pull a South Korea and ramp up its aid to Ukraine in response, they've been pretty disappointing lately, so I wouldn't exactly hold my breath.  Though I do foresee unexplained explosions in Iran in the future.

And finally, US diplomat found dead in Kyiv Hotel which sounds super serious and possibly some sort of assassination.  But for those rare few of us who read beyond the headlines - it was an embassy attaché and the death was from natural causes, as far as anyone knows.  Sometimes, real life isn't like a Tom Clancy novel.  Sometimes, people just drop dead.  No shadowy assassin.  Hug your pets and pet your kids, folks.

Hydra009

#4043

Ukraine strikes Russian s-500 anti-air system in Crimea


The s-500 system was Russia's latest and greatest air defense - allegedly able to intercept all ballistic and even hypersonic missiles currently in use.  And it was just developed in 2021 and sent to the front no earlier than April.  We're talking so new the plastic wrap hasn't been peeled off yet.

And it's gone, though of course, that still needs to be confirmed.  Russia only has 4 of these things so far and they cost around $600 million usd each, so losing any of them would be a tremendous setback.  Especially since this one was brought into Crimea to shore up the AA because of other AA losses.  The logic of sending more AA into an area where AA routinely go pop and then sending even more when those go pop is a bit difficult for me to grasp, but I'm not a big-time military genius like Putin, so what do I know.

Hydra009

Liked fuhrer all the wrong reasons: Pro-war Russian poet really just an anti-war poet who cobbled together poems from Nazi Germany to protest Putin

QuoteStarting in mid-2023, 18 poems appeared on the Kremlin's version of Facebook in the name of "Gennady Rakitin", saluting the heroic sacrifices of Russian soldiers and the noble leadership of Vladimir Putin.

One of these, titled On Holy Night, described "whispering to a dear son for the last time and dying for our peaceful Donbas". It has now been revealed as a tweaked translation of a poem written to inspire Nazi soldiers towards the end of the Second World War.

Another, The Leader, was published next to a photograph of Putin sitting on a thicket of shrubs. It described the Russian president as a "gardener" reaping the "fruits of hard labour" who is loved by his people and whose "immortality is rising".

But this was not a new poem inspired by Putin's invasion, it was a translation of a 1938 verse about Adolf Hitler written by Eberhard Moeller – an anti-Semite and Nazi propagandist – and Rakitin, its "author", did not exist.
Not a particularly media literate or history literate audience.

The poet is in exile already, so he's relatively safe.

Dark Lightning

Quote from: Hydra009 on June 29, 2024, 06:56:52 PMLiked fuhrer all the wrong reasons: Pro-war Russian poet really just an anti-war poet who cobbled together poems from Nazi Germany to protest Putin
Not a particularly media literate or history literate audience.

The poet is in exile already, so he's relatively safe.

...as long he doesn't eat sushi, and stays away from higher story windows.

Hydra009


Hydra009


Hydra009

#4048
Russian losses have been absolutely crushing this past month.  Almost every day was >1000 infantry casualties.  And this month, Russia reportedly lost more troops than it recruited.  Russia reportedly recruits about 30k new troops every month to offset losses.  But this month, it reportedly lost 33,920, generating a manpower loss of nearly 4000.  It's not enough to turn the tide, but if it's sustained or deepened, then month after month, and year after year, Russian manpower will falter.  That is, unless they counter with another mass mobilization or a huge influx of foreign troops, like the North Korean ones reportedly willing to co-invade Ukraine (while Germany and other allies worry about escalating things, Russia and North Korea are apparently under no such restraint)

Zelenskyy has reported that Russian casualties are roughly 6 times higher than Ukrainian casualties.  And Russian casualties are reportedly around 542700 so far, so that gives around 90,450 Ukrainian casualties.  That number is high enough to be bad for Ukraine, but it's downright catastrophic for Russia, which simply cannot conquer all of Ukraine with such a ratio.  They'd have to create a military many times larger than their current forces in order for that to happen - an impossibility given their current provisions (ancient equipment, even older rifles, and "tactical sneakers" are among the current provisions, with the "good" equipment consisting of turtle tanks and chinese-made ATVs)

Reportedly, a Russian airborne brigade (its current most elite troops, albeit heavily mauled over two years of fighting and used mostly near the hottest parts of the front) was reportedly harmed so badly that it was no longer able to continue operations and was forced to retreat (notably, with many refusals to fight, which is a surprise for its elite troops)

Despite its mathematical impossibility, Putin appears committed to a protracted, creeping advance strategy against Ukraine with the ultimate goal of the total destruction of the Ukrainian state.  So long as this creeping advance continues to yield territory, no matter how small, Putin appears unwilling - or unable - to recognize its unsustainability and ultimate futility until such time as it becomes painfully obvious that it won't work, and probably long after that.  Bear in mind that this guy's view of the war comes directly from reports from his subordinates - who are incentivized to lie to him - not independent news organizations or other countries.

It goes without saying that countries friendly to Ukraine can significantly hasten the day of Putin's ultimate realization.

Hydra009

Wounded Russian troops reportedly sent back to the frontline

QuoteA Russian milblogger claimed on June 29 that Russian military commanders sent about 50 wounded soldiers of the 26th Tank Regiment (47th Tank Division, 1st Guards Tank Army, Moscow Military District [MMD]), who are on leave awaiting medical treatments, to the front against doctors' instructions.[81] The milblogger claimed that this is a systemic issue that has been ongoing for a long time. A second milblogger claimed that Russian military commanders are sending wounded soldiers to fight since Russian servicemembers remain in service while receiving treatment due to the ban on dismissals except in extreme circumstances.[82] The milblogger also claimed that the Russian military is dismissing wounded soldiers from hospitals early due to overcrowding and is sending wounded personnel back to active units due to excessive losses. Russian State Duma Deputy Yaroslav Nilov stated on June 29 that he would send a request to the Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) and Chief Military Prosecutor's Office to resolve this issue after the first milblogger contacted Nilov.[83]

Russian independent journalist project "Irkutsk Blog" reported on June 26 that satellite imagery shows that the number of graves at some military cemeteries in Irkutsk Oblast has increased four-to-six times in the past year.[84]
Yikes.  How effective these squads of wounded Russian troops are is anyone's guess.  My guess is not great.

There are also reports of cholera and typhus spreading among Russian units.  Russian troops have long complained about not having enough safe drinking water, forcing them to collect and drink some combination of rainwater, puddle water, and water from nearby streams.  Needless to say, this is very likely to spread disease.

It really is the fundamentals that make or break an army.  Comparatively simple things like clean water, shells, and properly inflated tires.